VICTA Book Club

Your book reviews!
14 to 29 years

Looking for inspiration on what to read next?

Read the reviews from your fellow book club members! Please make sure you check the recommended age for individual titles before reading.

VICTA Book Club 14 to 29s

Books for children / teens

Title: Ella Jones vs the Sun Stealer
Author: Lucy Edwards
Genre: Adventure fiction: VI character
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Felicity (15)
Reader rating: 5 stars

Ella Jones vs the Sun Stealer by Lucy Edwards is an interesting funny story. It is accessible in many different formats and I have read the Braille copy and listened to the audio version. I couldn’t put this book down because it was so relatable and I truly felt like I was there with Ella. I could relate so much to Ella and her life and she has a similar personality to me, making her my favourite character. Ella Jones is blind with a guide dog, Maisie. Her friend, Finn is mad about Greek Gods’ mythology and after a school trip to a Greek mythological museum, Ella and her older sister become deeply interested in Greek Gods too. The next day Finn, Ella, her sister, Poppy and their parents have a day in London. But then the world turns black because Lugh, a Greek God escaped! Ella and her friends must find the seven rainbow stones hidden round London and slot them into the wooden shield before Lugh does!

It is an adventurous quest, bringing out strong friendship, bravery, skills that only the Blind have. There is funny parts in the scariest of times in this story. It has a happy ending. I would definitely read this book again! I would recommend this fictional novel to children aged 9+, who have a desire for adventure and are prepared to be brought into a different world. Out of five stars I would give the book five and I was delighted because I knew there was more Ella Jones books on the way.

Title: The Girl Who wasn’t There
Author: Karen McCombie
Genre: General fiction
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Felicity (15)
Reader rating: 5 stars

The Girl Who Wasn’t There by Karen McCombie is an amazing book. I have read it in Contracted Braille. This book is accessible to all, fun, engaging, sad and gripping. Maisie, her sister, Clem and their dad move to a cottage on the grounds of a school. Dad works as Nightingale School’s new site manager. Maisie keeps thinking that she is seeing a ghost from her bedroom window but everyone turns this idea down and gives firm, rational explanations. Maisie joins the school’s art club and can definitely feel a ghostly presence in the art room. Sure enough, one afternoon the schoolgirl ghost appears to her. Rumours have buzzed about the school for years about the ghost being Victorian and evil but the ghost is from the 1980s and is not evil. Maisie makes it her mission to find out how her ghost friend, Kat died. Kat doesn’t remember. Maisie’s dad’s girlfriend turns out to be Kat’s little sister. When she comes round for tea, she confides how Kat died. Nightingale school have a memorial for Kat.

Each chapter starts with a positive quote Maisie has found in her mother’s scrapbook, which is full of photographs and messages from her mother. I thoroughly recommend this book to people who like a little bit of spook topped with sadness and humour entangled in everything.

I would give this book five stars. My favourite character is Maisie because she is funny, honest and kind.

Title: The Seaside Sleepover
Author: Jacqueline Wilson
Genre: Fiction
Age: Children, teens
Reviewed by: Felicity (15)
Reader rating: 4 stars

The Seaside Sleepover by Jacqueline Wilson is a heartfelt, fictional book about a family holiday. The story is accessible in different formats and I have listened to the audio version twice. I find this book really fun to listen to and I can completely loose myself in it. My favourite character is Daisy; the story is told through her eyes. I like Daisy because she is kind, determined and animal loving. When Daisy’s summer holiday starts with the old next door neighbour breaking his hip, his dog, Scruff becomes Daisy’s pet temparorily. This makes it completely impossible to go on a holiday, with Daisy’s sister, Lily, who has learning difficulty and uses a wheelchair AND an energetic dog. Daisy is very unhappy about this but then … At Rabbit Cove there is no-stairs in the barn and Daisy knows this is the perfect place to have a holiday. Besides her uncle Gary is working at Rabbit Cove Theatre. Lily’s friend Natalie comes along for the trip. Scruff has lots of fields to run in and Daisy makes a very special friend, Beauty. They play together every day and go alpaca walking. Daisy and her family watch uncle Gary’s show at the theatre and on the second night of the holiday, Beauty, Daisy, Lily and Natalie have a sleepover in a tent beside the beach. But … Daisy’s least favourite girl from school comes to join in the sleepover! Scruff escapes and is very nearly over the cliff edge! With teamwork from everyone they rescue Scruff. I would recommend this book to primary children because it is a fun, easy read. I would also recommend this book to teachers because it teaches students about disability, family life and inclusivity in a fun way.

Out of five stars, I would give the book four as I felt the ending was rather abrupt and I wanted to know more about the rest of the holiday.

Title: The Worst Witch to the Rescue
Author: Jill Murphy
Genre: Fiction
Age: Children, teens
Reviewed by: Felicity (15)
Reader rating: 4 stars

The Worst Witch to the Rescue by Jill Murphy is a novella full of humour and retable emotions. Mildred Hubble is a witch at Miss Cackle’s Academy and everything always seems to go wrong for her. She is the worst witch in the school but always has one act of bravery. This book is part of a series. This is my favourite book in the series because it is the one with the most adventure and humour in it. Mildred’s enemy, Ethel, is being unusually friendly and on the first morning of school the girls sit together in a tree chatting about Mildred’s wonderful holiday project. But then Mildred’s bag falls down the tree. Ethel picks everything up. In the Art class, the teacher praises Mildred’s work and Ethel asks to look at it and turns her clay models into snakes. Then that afternoon, Ethel reads out Mildred’s holiday project, having stolen it from Mildred whilst picking up the possessions that fell out of Mildred’s bag. Ethel has replaced Mildred’s work with little drawings and the formidable teacher is not impressed. That night, Ethel and her friend steal Mildred’s tortoise and hide it in a tree. They do this because the tortoise can talk and can back Mildred up about the holiday project incident. However, Mildred goes and rescues the tortoise in the middle of a storm. Ethel, Mildred, the headteacher, Miss Cackle and their formidable teacher have a meeting and Ethel admits her mistakes. I would give this book four stars because I really enjoyed it but I felt there could have been more detail in some parts. It has a good lesson about always telling the truth. I recommend this book to young people because it is a fun read. I have listened to the audio version, which has a good narrator.

Title: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
Author: C. S. Lewis
Genre: Adventure
Age: Children, teens
Reviewed by: Baquero (16)
Reader rating: Loved it!

I loved the Narnia book. My favourite character was Lucy. The witch is horrible. There are lots of different characters.

Title: Ella Enchanted
Author: Gail Carson Levine
Genre: Fantasy, fairytale
Age: Children, teens
Reviewed by: Karima (25)
Reader rating: 4 stars

Ella enchanted is a heartwarming whimsically creative retelling of Cinderella. The protagonist (Ella) receives the “gift” of obedience from a misguided fairy, forcing her to obey any order given, regardless of the consequences. Determined to be free, Ella goes on a quest to break the spell and live happily ever after. Along the way she will meet giants, outwits ogres and dance with princes.

Previously, I had only seen the movie adaptation featuring Anne Hathaway. Upon learning how different the book is from the movie, I decided to give it a read. And I’m extremely glad I did!

I love the way Cinderella is depicted in this version. Ella is more outwardly rebellious, humorous and clever. All without losing the signature gentleness of the original princess.

Throughout the story Ella is forced to deal with those who would exploit her via the spell. But in a very Matilda-esque fashion, she finds ways to circumvent orders. It was a pleasant surprise to see an author unafraid to explore the darker reality of a world without free will. Although not under a spell like Ella, there are still those in world whose freedoms have been taken away. Reading this story gave me a deeper sense of appreciation for my ability to choose.

Despite touching upon more serious themes, the story still maintains the same sense of wander and hope I’ve come to anticipate in fairytales. Ella’s relationship with the prince is especially sweet. The book covers a period of about two years. During which we experience the shift from friendship to love as the characters get to know each other. In a time where rivalmances have become more common place. It was really nice read about a cute and wholesome romance.

Overall a great read. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for the nostalgia of a fairytale but with the maturity of a YA. Star Rating:4/5

Title: Fake Skating
Author: Lynn Painter
Genre: Humour
Age: Teens
Reviewed by: Danielle (21)
Reader rating: Funny & sweet!

This book was funny, sweet and easy to read. I loved reading the main characters development. It was also like watching a movie where the descriptions are so good I could visualise what was happening in my head.

Title: The Upside of Falling
Author: Alex Light
Genre: Relationships
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Danielle (21)
Reader rating: Not enjoyable

I didn’t like this book, it felt predictable and it times just not enjoyable. I didn’t like the character development and st times it just wasnt enjoyable at all.

Title: Night of Iron and Ink
Author: Shannen Durey
Genre: Fiction
Age: Teen (Paige recommends 18+)
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 5 stars

This book was a solid 5 stars. I cried, I laughed, I shouted at the book characters. At one point I even had to put the book down to process the plot twist. Night of Iron and Ink is a Dark Romantasy. Vera is our FMC who was raised by an evil witch who put a curse on her so she would turn into a half-beast with talons and fangs. Ronan is the Fae’s elite enforcer, he knows when one of the two Fae laws have been broken within The Lands and will deal with the mortals who committed the crime. One day Ronan lays eyes on Vera and both of their worlds change. Vera is tasked by the Rogues – a group of halflings who fight against the Fae – to retrieve a weapon that could take out all of the immortal Fae’s. However this doesn’t go the way Vera believed it would, and she becomes bound in a deal with Ronan, not expecting how their journey together would go.

Nights of Iron and Ink is the first book of four in the darkest flame series. The book wasn’t left on a cliffhanger, however the ending was sure to draw anyone in to read the next book as soon as they could. There were plot twists that made you gasp, moments that made you laugh, and you got so connected to the two main characters you would shout at them whenever they did something dumb. It was a rollercoaster of a book but was amazing. The pacing of the book was fantastic, there were fast paced moments and the quiet moments alongside it that would make you think. I would recommended this book to anyone 18+ because of some of the open door romance scenes and themes of trauma throughout the book.

Title: Night of Steel and Shadow
Author: Shannen Durey
Genre: Fiction
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 4.75

Night of Steel and Shadow is the second book in the darkest flame series. It follows Vera and Ronan fighting to figure out how to trust each other after the betrayals they went through towards the end of the first book. Vera realises she is in love with Ronan and tries to do everything in her power to get Ronan to arrest her but fails as Kian stops all her attempts at breaking Fae Law. After Vera is sentenced to death for her crimes in Mayhem, Ronan comes in to save her and bring her back to the Fae lands. The Nighters have the Godstone and plan on destroying the barrier at the next blood moon and releasing the beasts on The Lands. Vera and Ronan must work through their hatred and hurt to find the Godstone before it is too late. But stronger forces have different ideas.

I would give this book a 4.75 stars out of 5. I love Ronan and Vera as characters, Vera had a awful childhood of abuse but is learning what love is supposed to feel like, is finding new friends, and figuring out how to trust her gut without the trauma influencing her. Ronan does everything that he can to prove Vera wrong and begs for her forgiveness for keeping a massive secret from her and lying to her for weeks. This book looses a quarter of a star because the miscommunication trope is too overused in this book and becomes frustrating at times. The ending is left on a cliffhanger that will take your breath away. My favourite scene is when Vera says she will give Rona five minutes to explain if he gets her ten Moonroses within two hours – Ronan is severely allergic to Moonroses but doesn’t even think about it as he sprints off to get them. I love this scene because it shows Ronan’s intense love for Vera and that he would do anything in his power for her no matter what

Title: Poison Study
Author: Maria V. Snyder
Genre: Fantasy
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 5 stars

The Chronicles of Ixia is one of my favourite fantasy series I have ever read. In Poison Study, we follow Yelena who was in the Commander’s dungeon for murder awaiting execution by hanging. However she is offered the chance to become the Commander’s food taster instead. She accepts and Valek starts to train her in the art of poisons. She serves the Commander for many seasons in Ixia, however, Master Magicians from their Southern friends in Sytia want her for other reasons. In Ixia, Magic is banned.

The writing in Poison study is really good, it’s not too fast and helps to build a detailed environment of the world around them without lacking drama and action. Potion Study also has a slow burn romance undertone. The Romance with the Fantasy is the perfect blend of the two, making you know all about the fantasy, with the lighthearted Romance that blooms along the way. I would rate Potion Stufy as a 5 Star book and recommend it to anyone 13+.

Title: Study of Poisons
Author: Maria V. Snyder
Genre: Fantasy
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 5 stars

Study of poisons is the next book chronologically in the chronicles of Ixia series. It is the same timeframe of the first book – Poison study – but comes from Valek’s POV instead. You get a full insight into the other events of the book during that time, how Valek fell for Yelena first, and his relationship with the Commander from a different perspective. It is another five star book, the pacing is good, it is well written, and being able to see the events and thought process of the first book makes you understand the world even better.

Title: Magic Study
Author: Maria V. Snyder
Genre: Fantasy
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 4 stars

Magic study is the third book in the Chronicles of Ixia series. It follows Yelena as she learns about her magic. She has been taken into Sytia with the other kidnapped orphans, she meets her family, and her brother Leaf. There is a threat against Sytia – Ferdinand, who is kidnapping young magicians and stealing their magic in a powerful blood ritual. Yelena, being a stubborn Ixian, tries to defeat him herself with her old Ixian habits, slowly learning that sometimes, the Sytian way can be better.

This book is a solid four stars. It is as always written wonderfully, the pacing is great and its a smooth transition from the first book, continuing her story as we are introduced to the other half of the world she lives in. Sytia is so much different to Ixia, so in some ways it feels like a completely different book with the same characters, but the transition is seamless and really draws you back into the world.

Title: Fire Study
Author: Maria V. Snyder
Genre: Fantasy
Age: Teen
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 4.5 stars

Fire Study is the final book in the original Chronical of Ixia series. It continues to follow Yelena and Valek through the trials of magi in Sytia. Ferdinand has been defeated, but not for long. When another threat comes to light threatening magicians across the land, Yelena has to work alongside her brother Leaf, her heartmate Valek, and learn the extent of her soulfinder abilities to bring down the new threat before it’s too late.

I would give this book a 4.5 stars out of 5. The pacing of the story was amazing, and it brought a whole new layer into the story of Yelena and Valek. We see more into the dangers against Valek in Ixia, and how his love with Yelena is strong enough that the man who is immune to magic, can suddenly become the strongest magicians strongest ally.

Books for adults

Title: Blind not Broken
Author: Lucy Edwards
Genre: Non-fiction
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Dayzie (17)
Reader rating: Relatable & authentic

I love how relatable and authentic it is. I enjoyed it.

Title: The Cheat Sheet
Author: Sarah Adams
Genre: Adventure
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Bickram (21)
Reader rating: Lighthearted & funny!

I really enjoyed reading the cheat sheet. It was like a 2000s rom com, at times predictable but still warm, lighthearted and funny. I love that thier relationship was was explored throughout the book rather than just being at the end like in most books. Im also a huge fan of Sarah adams books in general so this was a nice way to unwind after a long day.

Title: A Discovery of Witches
Author: Deborah Harkness
Genre: Fantasy, horror
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Erin (21)
Reader rating: Really exciting!

The book was great and really exciting, it’s a fantasy book about witches, vampires and demons. I didn’t want to stop reading, and finished it quite quickly. It is a fantasy fiction book.

Title: The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
Author: Annie Barrows and Mary Ann Shaffer
Genre: General fiction
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Erin (21)
Reader rating: Really enjoyed it!

I really enjoyed this book, and because it’s quite a small book I finished it relatively quickly which was bittersweet. This book was different to any that I had read before in the fact that it was comprised of only letters back and forth between the characters. This kept me interested in the story, which was set during WW2 and the lives that people on Guernsey lived during that time.

Title: The Housemaid
Author: Frieda McFadden
Genre: Psychological thriller
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Dayzie (17)
Reader rating: 5 stars

After watching the audio described film of The Housemaid and loving it, I decided to download the book for it. It is a psychological thriller with loads of twists along the way and you realise not everything is what it seems like. I would rate it 5 stars. It really is a great start to my reading journey.

Title: The Honey Witch
Author: Sydney J. Shields
Genre: Fantasy, horror, romance
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Levi (20)

At first, I really wasn’t enjoying this book, but I had heard such good things about it from my friends that I knew I had to keep going. I started to get really invested when Marigold was noticing small things about herself that had gone unanswered, and when Althea came to give her all of these answers I didn’t want to put it down. I did not expect the romance aspect of this book at all in the beginning but as soon as she started questioning her curse of never being able to love somebody I knew there must be more to it. I LOVED the fact that her and Lottie were willing to try to fight for their relationship no matter the consequences, they knew there must be a way to work around this curse because they truly loved one another. I felt so emotional when she started to rekindle her relationship with her mum, the whole last half of the book had my emotions heightened

Title: Throne of Glass
Author: Sarah J. Maas
Genre: Fantasy, romance, thriller
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Ruqayyah (27)

A romantasy book following Feyre Archeron, her family, her life and eventually her journey to Prythian. Throne of glass is a thrilling series following a young woman and her struggles. The Book is filled with action adventure romance and much much more fantastical storylines. My favourite character is between Aelin Lysnadra and Elide.

Title: Kingdom of Ash
Author: Sarah J. Maas
Genre: Fantasy, romance, thriller
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Ruqayyah (27)

Sarah J. Mass has created a world of love, hate, happiness, grief with fay humans, witches, demons, shape shifters, healers and much much more. The story follows Aelin Galathinius Ashrive a long lost princes who loved her kingdom very very much. Her family were all assassinated when she was a child. She was chased in an assassination attempt fir many years. Her aim was to reclaim her kingdom and free the world from a demon prince of hell.

This story is amazing and can be resold as a fairytale for children.

Title: Bound by Threads
Author: N E Stevenson
Genre: Dark romance
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 4.5 stars

I really enjoyed this book. It was about a girl who had a broken childhood, her parents were drug addicts and she was bullied and tormented at high school by her three exes who want to break her more. She faked her death and ran away to the other side of the country, changing her name so she wouldn’t be found but when her past comes back to get her, she finds herself the same broken girl she was 2 years ago. Its a Why Choose dark romance, and the first book in a duet. I thought the writting was a little off and it didn’t flow the best, some chapters felt like they were filler chapters and the book would have still worked without them in it, but the overall plot and story was amazing and kept me reading, I couldn’t put the book down at all! I don’t really have a favourite character, but Oscar might just take the win at the moment, he is a deaf male character and one of the love interests, he has some humour and is very protective over Lottie with everything he does is to protect her from her past and help her to have a happy future again.

I would recommend this book to anyone 18+ who is new to Dark Romance, as it has some darker themes in it but is still a heartwarming love story, and the ending will leave you wanting to read the second book straight away.

I would give it 4.5 stars out of 5 because mostly how it is written and the amount of filler chapters, but the plot and charcters and story are definitely worth the read.

Title: Damaged
Author: Sheridan Anne
Genre: Romantic fiction
Age: Adult (18+ only – dark topics)
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 4.5 stars

I would give Damaged 4.5 stars out of 5. It was one of those books that was amazing to read, whilst you’re reading it, but by the end of it you forget what happened during most of the book. This is the second book in the Boys of Winter series. This book perfectly carried on from the cliff-hanger of the first book, making my jaw drop reading it. It once again had a slight problem with the pacing of the book and it felt like several books had been crammed into one, and the timeline felt too rushed. There was plot twists that you could see coming from a mile away, which made the plot twists you didn’t see coming even more jaw dropping. Once again this book ended on a cliff-hanger that made me start reading the next book straight away I couldn’t put it down. Winter has now settled into her new role as the head of a secret society, but some people don’t like that she is female and are trying to take her out so they can take over instead. The writing was once again amazing, and the characters felt real, they interrupted each other whilst talking, was playful and acting realistically towards each other. My favourite character is Cruz, he is the sunshine of the group of misfits, always has something cocky or witty to say and a lot of his scenes have made me laugh.

There is a lot of smut in this book and so I would not recommend it to anyone who isn’t willing to read that, even I ended up skimming through a lot of those chapters as it became almost too much. This is an 18+ book again and covers some dark topics but in a very good and realistic way for them to be covered, not making them out to be a joke.

Title: Devient
Author: Sheridan Anne
Genre: Romantic fiction
Age: Adult (18+ only – dark topics)
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 4.5 stars

I would give Deviant a 4.5 stars out of 5. Deviant is the third book in the Boys of Winter series, and this time the pacing was a lot better. It didn’t feel too rushed and was cramming too much into it at once. The wiring was again, very smooth, realistic and easy to read along to. My favourite character is still Cruz, he is still bringing the sunshine and witty personality into the group, and has a way of brightening up any dark situation that they find themselves in. Now Winter and her boys know who really is after her and has been for the last 18 years, they are able to prepare themselves for the war that is about to start a lot better. There are a lot of loose ends that get tied up during this book, several more jaw dropping plot twists, and yet another cliff-hanger that had me starting the next book instantly.

I read this book in one day, not being able to put it down after the cliff-hanger from the second book and wanting to find out more about what was going to happen. I would recommend this book to anyone 18+ who is into dark why choose romances. The slow burn from all of the guys finally ends and she admits her true feelings towards them, and worry about their lives during all of the chaos, vowing to protect them as much as they are protecting her, until the end of the book where everything she thought she knew is thrown out the of window and left for the reader to think about before the next book.

Title: Deity
Author: Sheridan Anne
Genre: Romantic fiction
Age: Adult (18+ only – dark topics)
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 5 stars

Deity is the final book in the boys of winter series and this was a solid 5 stars out of 5 stars. The ending was jaw dropping and satisfying all in one, and the epilogue and extended epilogue would make any romantic squeal reading it. The pacing of this book was amazing and was able to tie up all the loose ends and unanswered questions, wrapping up every plot point with a satisfying ending. I would definitely suggest reading the trigger warnings on this book before diving into it as there are some scene that are not everyone’s cup of tea. Winter finally got her happy ending, along with her four boys. She became the leader that Dynasty needed and started up a new way for Dynasty to run that would help people and not fall into corruption and misconception again.

Overall, I would rate the series of Boys of Winter a 4.75 stars out of 5 and would suggest anyone to read it, push through the first book and you will get a very happy ending.

Title: Close to You
Author: Nissa Renzo
Genre: Romantic fiction
Age: Adult (18+ only)
Reviewed by: Paige (24)
Reader rating: 5 stars

This book was hands down one of the best I have read so far this year. This Dark Romance but soft romance book follows Millow, a mute, through her life into her teenage years. She lived a terrible childhood at a young age before she escaped and found a Fire station. She was taken into care, but when the firefighter she had connected with and his wife appear to adopt her, she is hesitant. Millow doesn’t speak, but that doesn’t stop her adopted brothers Wesley and Ashby don’t treat her any differently they try to learn sign language so that they can communicate with her in their own secret language. Growing up, Millow was bullied constantly for being a mute, but her family and new friends stuck by her and made her feel loved, When a twist comes at the end it almost breaks Millow and Ashby, but their love for each other has grown over the years and blossomed into something beautiful when they needed each other the most.

This book is recommended for 18+ because of the dark themes throughout the book, however, the rest of the book is such a sweet romance it will get you giggling, crying and every emotion in-between. Make sure to have the tissues ready for the heartbreak you will experience. I would give this book a solid 5 out of 5 stars. The writing is well paced and is descriptive to give you a good picture of everything throughout the book.

Title: Legendary
Author: Stephanie Garber
Genre: Fantasy, horror
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Ropafadzo (25)
Reader rating: 3 stars

Legendary is the second book in the Caraval series by Stephanie Garber. This instalment shifts focus from Scarlett Dragna to her sister, Donatella (Tella) Dragna. In a desperate attempt to secure their freedom, Tella makes a dangerous bargain with a mysterious criminal. To uphold her end of the deal, she must once again enter – and win – Caraval.

I absolutely love books with point of view shifts. It’s a simple yet effective way to provide greater insight into different characters while also easing the use of creative literary devices such as juxtaposition and dramatic irony.

However, I was a little disappointed this time around. As much as I enjoyed getting to know Tella better, I didn’t like that Scarlett’s development was largely sidelined in the process. It’s clear throughout the novel that Scarlett continues to grow after the events of the first book, but because the story is told through Tella’s perspective, we don’t get to witness that growth ourselves.

Arguably, this was inevitable. Since the first book, it’s been made clear that although Tella is Scarlett’s entire world, the reverse isn’t quite true. As a result, even when Tella notices that Scarlett is struggling and likely needs support, those moments are often brushed aside as Tella becomes consumed by her own goals. This is entirely consistent with Tella’s character, but it also means the reader misses out on seeing Scarlett’s continued development. I found that disappointing, especially considering Scarlett was the emotional centre of the first novel and the original catalyst for the events of the series.

That said, it was fascinating to learn more about Tella herself and to discover everything that had been happening behind the scenes during the events of the previous book—things Scarlett never knew and therefore could never have narrated.

The novel also introduces a fun premise that expands both the world-building and the history of its characters. Unfortunately, I found many of the major plot twists to be fairly predictable, and some of their reveals felt a little rushed. Predictability isn’t necessarily a problem in itself—many stories remain emotionally powerful even when you know what’s coming—but the execution needs to give those moments room to breathe.

For example, I still cry every time Mufasa dies in The Lion King, despite knowing exactly what’s going to happen, because the emotional build-up and payoff are executed so well. I think Legendary could have benefited from dedicating just a page or two more to some of its biggest reveals so that readers had more time to fully experience the emotions they were meant to evoke.

Despite these criticisms, I still think Stephanie Garber has created a beautiful world filled with wonder and magic. What makes the Caraval series so enchanting is that its fantasy feels grounded in a world that closely resembles our own. It’s as though reality has simply been sprinkled with whimsy—our world, but where apples are blue, luck can be bought and traded, and the impossible feels just believable enough to exist. Every scene carries a touch of Alice in Wonderland, reminding the reader to keep looking for magic and wonder in everyday life.

That being said, I’m still undecided about whether I’ll read the final book in the trilogy. Legendary is certainly an enjoyable read, but it’s not one I can see myself returning to.

Overall, I’m giving Legendary 3 out of 5 stars.

Title: Carmilla
Author: Sheridan Le Fanu
Genre: Horror, ghost stories
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Levi (20)
Reader rating: 4 stars

I thought Carmilla was wonderfully written, showing the pure love and passion between the two girls, the book is mysterious and just truly an exciting read. This book only took me an hour and a half to read as it is short, but I think it ended exactly at the right point, what was this mysterious illness and who was this girl?
This book has definitely gotten me into an autumnal mood, and I now want to read Dracula, as this actually is the same sort of vibe, and came before Dracula.

I would rate this book a 4 stars. It was short, mysterious and gripping.

Title: Disappearing Nightly
Author: Laura Resnick
Genre: Science fiction, fantasy
Age: Adult
Reviewed by: Ropafadzo (25)
Reader rating: 4 stars

Disappearing Nightly — 4/5 stars; Disappearing Nightly was a lot of fun and exactly what I needed after reading a couple of really dark novels. It’s light-hearted, funny and refreshingly different from a lot of other urban fantasy; One of my favourite things about the book is how original both the protagonist and the premise feel within the genre. Esther Diamond is a struggling actress in New York, rather than the powerful supernatural heroine or hard-boiled vigilante you might expect. There are no vampires or werewolves appearing as either antagonists or mysterious love interests. Instead, Esther is completely mundane. She has no special powers, combat skills, extraordinary perception or genius intellect. As she essentially puts it herself, she isn’t a heroine — she just plays them. At the beginning of the story, Esther is working as the understudy to pop star Golly Gee in Sorcerer!, an off-Broadway musical centred around stage magic. During a performance, Golly disappears as part of the show — except this time she doesn’t reappear. When Esther starts looking into what happened, she discovers that magicians’ assistants are mysteriously disappearing across New York. With reason to suspect she could become one of the next victims, she rather reluctantly finds herself dragged into investigating. Esther being so ordinary is one of the book’s greatest strengths. She isn’t fearlessly charging towards danger because she feels destined to save everyone. She’s chaotic, funny and frequently just trying to get through the increasingly bizarre situation she has found herself in. A large part of her motivation for solving the mystery is simply the very reasonable desire not to end up as its next victim. Watching a completely mundane struggling actress attempt to balance work, romance and everyday life while investigating a magical conspiracy was a wonderfully refreshing take on urban fantasy. In some ways, the book reminded me of a light-hearted urban fantasy version of Doctor Who.

The story manages to be simultaneously fantastical and remarkably down to earth. Strange magical events are happening throughout New York, but Esther still has to worry about auditions, acting jobs, money and her love life. That contrast gives the supernatural elements an almost whimsical quality. The supporting cast adds considerably to the comedy, and there is also a romantic subplot involving Connor Lopez, an attractive police officer who becomes entangled in Esther’s investigation. The romance is probably one of the less developed aspects of this first book, but it feels as though it has deliberately been left room to grow over the course of the series rather than being intended as a major focus here.

At its heart, Disappearing Nightly is as much a mystery novel as an urban fantasy. There are plenty of twists, suspects and red herrings, both magical and mundane, as Esther tries to work out what is actually happening to the missing performers. Importantly, while there are clearly elements that can continue into later books, the central mystery is fully resolved. It therefore works perfectly well as a standalone story rather than feeling like an extended introduction to a series.

Overall, Disappearing Nightly is a quick, funny and charming read. Its greatest strength is the contrast between an increasingly ridiculous magical mystery and a protagonist who is hilariously, stubbornly ordinary. I particularly enjoyed seeing urban fantasy from the perspective of someone who isn’t a supernatural powerhouse and really would rather not be involved in any of this. I’d recommend it to anyone looking for some fluffy, humorous urban fantasy, particularly as a palate cleanser after something darker or heavier. It feels like the sort of book that would be perfect for a lazy summer day.

Reading resources and book inspiration

Reading recommendations for Year 11s (15 to 16s)
Find out more on School Reading List >

Check out RNIB’s reading resource centre
Visit RNIB Online Reading Service >

More practical activities and resources for VI readers
Visit Path to Literacy >

Discover vision impaired author Beth O’Brien with Calibre Audio

Join the club!

Terms and conditions

  • The VICTA Book Club is open to children and young adults aged 5 to 29 years who are registered or are registrable as blind or partially sighted as per our requirements for support; you may be asked to provide supporting documentation of your/your child’s vision impairment. Any questions regarding eligibility, please contact students@victa.org.uk
  • Entrants must be permanent residents of the UK
  • For each stage, entrants must complete at least one review within the stated time period
  • Please note, the actual patches and keyrings you receive may differ to any illustrations. Patches will be sent after each section closes. There may be delays in sending out rewards dependent on stock
  • By submitting a review, you are confirming that you are happy for VICTA to share it on the VICTA Book Club site.

Tell us what you’ve been reading lately and share your review

Applicant details

Leave your review

Confirmation of vision impairment

To qualify for this activity the lead applicant (your VI child) must be either registered or registerable as blind or partially sighted (sight impaired/severely sight impaired). VICTA will ask for supporting evidence post application if we have not previously received it.

related stories

Read and share!

  • Erin's Braille Mission

Erin’s Braille Mission

February 12, 2026|0 Comments

As her entry into VICTA's recent Braille Art Competition, Erin wrote an incredible braille adventure story that we just had to share with you! We hope you enjoy this wonderful ode to braille... It [...]

My braille journey

June 25, 2025|0 Comments

By Eliza Humphrey Hello, I am Eliza, a VICTA Changemaker and life-long braille user. I have been blind since birth and have always used braille to read and write. For me, it [...]